"Working 'from' India is very different from working 'for' India," financial planner Akshat Shrivastava wrote in a recent post on X (formerly Twitter), sparking an intense debate on economic contribution and national identity.
Shrivastava argued that an NRI creating jobs from abroad could be doing more for India than a resident who benefits from government freebies without contributing to growth.
"If you are a rich NRI who works from Dubai and creates 10 jobs in India, you are doing more than someone who lives in India, takes a freebie, demands two more freebies, and cries about people leaving India," he wrote.
His post resonated with many users.
"Interesting take! I’ve always thought about this tension. Do you think there’s a middle ground? Some NRIs contribute economically but don't engage with India's social challenges, while some residents might not create jobs but strengthen communities in other ways," one user commented.
Another echoed the sentiment: "Exactly! Contribution isn’t about physical presence — it’s about value creation. Building businesses, creating jobs, and investing in the economy matter far more than just staying put and complaining. What’s your take on reversing brain drain?"
Others highlighted the role of remittances. "NRIs help India's economy grow by sending money back home. These remittances support families and boost the country’s foreign exchange reserves, which strengthens the economy," one user wrote.
However, not everyone agreed.
"Who is contributing more to the Indian economy — NRIs or local taxpayers? Remittances play a vital role, but local taxpayers bear the daily burden of development," a critic countered.
Another user pushed back against Shrivastava's framing: "This is a very disrespectful way to look at people who are building for India. Not everyone takes a freebie. Not everyone is privileged to move out of the country. Labeling people this way is blind ignorance."
Shrivastava’s post has ignited a broader conversation on how contribution to the country should be measured — by physical presence, financial impact, or something more.